Jeongnyeon: The Star is Born Episode 9 Review: Shattered Dreams and Hurtful Lies

In the previous intense episode, the Maeran troupe girls prepare rigorously for their group play auditions, sparking rivalries, partnerships, and emotional turmoil. When Jooran chooses Yeong-seo over Jeongnyeon as her partner, Jeongnyeon feels deeply betrayed, igniting a fierce competitive drive within her. Ignoring warnings from Chorok and So-bok, Jeongnyeon subjects herself to relentless, self-destructive practice, following misguided advice from Hye-rang to push herself to the brink.

By audition day, Jeongnyeon’s voice is severely strained, yet she summons every ounce of her emotional resilience to deliver a moving performance with Chorok that leaves the audience spellbound, even as it costs her physical health. The episode closes with Jeongnyeon collapsing, and the consequences of her ambition are painfully evident to all.

Directed by Jung Ji-in, this series offers a glimpse into the post-war theatre world, capturing the ambition, rivalry, and personal struggles of its characters.

– Contains Spoilers –

Jeongnyeon: The Star is Born Episode 9 Recap

The episode opens with Jeongnyeon being rushed to the hospital after collapsing during her intense audition performance. Meanwhile, at the auditorium, the results are announced, and Young-seo and Jooran are named as the leads. This decision, though a triumph for the Maeran troupe, causes an uproar among the other troupes who feel it’s unfair that both main roles went to Maeran members. Caught off guard by the spotlight and the cameras flashing, Young-seo runs offstage, struggling with feelings of guilt and self-doubt. Deep down, she feels that Jeongnyeon, who poured everything into her performance, deserves the role more.

The next day, Young-seo meets her mother, Ki-joo, who casually mentions that she bribed the judges to secure the role for her. Shocked and upset, Young-seo confronts her mother, declaring that she’s done living for her mother’s approval and that, from now on, she’ll live as herself and not as Ki-joo’s daughter. Later, So-bok reassures Young-seo, revealing that the decision to cast her was, in fact, unanimous and not influenced by her mother’s bribe. She encourages Young-seo to have confidence in her talent, affirming that she’s every bit as gifted as Jeongnyeon and that it’s her time to shine. Feeling reassured, Young-seo finally allows herself to be proud of her achievement.

Also read: A Virtuous Business Episode 9 Review: Balancing Friendships Amidst Crisis

Jeongnyeon is discharged from the hospital, where she learns the devastating news that she might never be able to sing pansori again due to severe damage to her vocal cords. Yet, determined and optimistic, she tells So-bok that she believes with enough rest and diligent practice, she can heal and return to her art one day. Back at the Maeran house, Jooran and Young-seo practice for their play, but there’s a somber mood, with both feeling the weight of Jeongnyeon’s situation. When Jeongnyeon arrives, Chorok warmly offers her steamed buns, a small gesture meant to cheer her up.

Young-seo approaches Jeongnyeon and, despite her inner turmoil, accepts her friend’s sincere congratulations. Jeongnyeon reassures her, stating that she earned the role purely on her talent. At rehearsal, the tension rises when an actor from the women’s theater group, cast in an antagonist role, begins to overact, disrupting the narrative flow. When So-bok politely asks her to adjust her performance, the actor refuses, and her group leader, Nam-hui, sides with her. The conflict leaves So-bok frustrated, as she senses that the group cares more about showcasing themselves than working together to enhance the story.

Meanwhile, Jeongnyeon’s desperation to regain her voice intensifies. Determined to try anything, she even considers using opium, despite the risks, hoping it might help her recover. When So-bok finds out, she confronts Jeongnyeon, trying to stop her from taking such extreme measures. Their argument escalates, with Jeongnyeon refusing to back down. In a last effort to help, So-bok promises to take her to a doctor in the United States who might offer solutions for her damaged voice.

Unfortunately, the American doctor delivers grim news: surgery could worsen the condition, leaving Jeongnyeon’s hopes in tatters. Overcome with frustration and anger, Jeongnyeon lashes out, causing a scene that leads So-bok to slap her in an attempt to calm her down. Feeling defeated, Jeongnyeon decides to leave the Maeran troupe. She leaves behind a simple letter for So-bok, then returns to her hometown, where her sister Jung-ja and mother welcome her with open arms. Her family, though supportive, is heartbroken to see her in such despair, and her mother gently reminds her that, in time, she will heal.

At home, Jeongnyeon struggles with her emotions, feeling lost and purposeless. While walking through the village, she hears a merchant singing—a sound that triggers a wave of bittersweet memories. She finds herself drawn to the sea, collapsing in anguish as she tries to process her loss. Back at the Maeran house, Chorok reveals to So-bok that Hye-rang was the one who encouraged Jeongnyeon to push herself dangerously hard. Furious, So-bok confronts Hye-rang and tells her that after their joint performance, she must leave the troupe. Hye-rang responds defiantly, threatening that if she’s forced to leave, Ok-kyeong will leave with her. But So-bok stands firm, confident that Ok-kyeong won’t let herself be manipulated.

Soon after, a scandal erupts when a newspaper publishes an article accusing Ok-kyeong of being an opium addict, shaking the theater community. Preparing for a press conference, Ok-kyeong declares her innocence and dares the anonymous witness to come forward and prove the accusation. Back at the Maeran house, she finds Young-seo practicing tirelessly. In a rare moment of vulnerability, Ok-kyeong encourages Young-seo, affirming her talent and telling her she earned the lead role on her own merit. Feeling reassured, Young-seo’s relief turns to shock when Ok-kyeong suddenly asks if she’d consider leaving the Maeran troupe to join her elsewhere, leaving Young-seo to question her next steps.

Jeongnyeon: The Star is Born Episode 9 Review

This episode dives deep into the emotional toll of ambition, revealing the vulnerability and resilience of the main characters. Jeongnyeon’s drive to succeed pushes her to extremes, leading to a physical and emotional breakdown that ultimately forces her to confront the limitations of her own body. Her desperation to retain her voice and identity as a singer, even considering opium to regain her strength, reflects the intense pressures faced by artists. The heartbreaking reality of her vocal damage and subsequent journey home illustrates how passion can sometimes turn self-destructive. Young-seo’s struggle with feelings of guilt and self-worth, especially after learning about her mother’s interference in the audition process, adds another layer of complexity.

The episode also heightens the tension within the Maeran troupe, especially with So-bok’s conflict with both the women’s theater group and Hye-rang. These scenes emphasize the challenges of leadership and the fine line between nurturing talent and enforcing discipline. So-bok’s interactions with Jeongnyeon, especially her attempts to help and ultimately discipline her, add a maternal yet conflicted aspect to her character, showing her struggle to balance support with tough love. The scandal surrounding Ok-kyeong brings an additional twist, putting the troupe’s reputation at stake and setting the stage for potential fractures among its members. Overall, this episode balances intense drama with quiet moments of introspection, highlighting the costs of ambition and the sacrifices artists make in their pursuit of excellence.

Jeongnyeon: The Star is Born is streaming on Disney+ Hotstar.

Also read: All Jeongnyeon: The Star is Born Reviews