Judges Show More Mercy After Lunch: Study

- Advertisement -

The saying, “Justice depends on what the judges ate for breakfast,” may have some truth to it. A study examined Israel judges who presided over parole hearings. It was observed that judges gave more merciful decisions at the start of the day and after lunch. Read on to see what this means!

The Study

For this social experiment, more than 1,000 rulings were studied. The authors observed that the judges granted parole 65% of the time to the first criminal. The probability decreased after that. After the lunch break, the chances increased to 65% once again and then declined as the day progressed. 

- Advertisement -

Jonathan Levav, who co-authored the paper said: “You are anywhere between two and six times as likely to be released if you’re one of the first three prisoners considered versus the last three prisoners considered.”

The only other things that had an effect on the judicial proceedings were the number of times a prisoner had been to jail and whether there was a rehabilitation program. Variables such as the severity of the prisoner’s crime, prison time, sex and ethnicity tended to not exert an effect on the rulings, according to the study.

Figure from the judges study
The proportion of rulings in favour of the prisoners by ordinal position. Circled points indicate the first decision in each of the three decision sessions; tick marks on x-axis denote every third case; dotted line denotes food break. Because unequal session lengths resulted in a low number of cases for some of the later ordinal positions, the graph is based on the first 95% of the data from each session.

The Reasons  

- Advertisement -

The authors say that making successive decisions draws from our limited mental faculty. When we get tired, we look for shortcuts like following the status quo. In this case – denying parole. This is based on the concept of Ego Depletion (not the colloquial ego). The hypothesis is that willpower and self-control are limited resources that diminish with use. However, they can effectively be replenished by consuming sugar (judges having lunch). 

Levav said: “I don’t measure the judge’s mood. I don’t measure the judge’s glucose level. It’s just a very consistent empirical regularity. It’s a quite robust effect, and it really doesn’t matter how you cut the data you get to reproduce it.”

tingey injury law firm DZpc4UY8ZtY unsplash

The Implications 

- Advertisement -

The studies suggest that the findings are applicable in a variety of scenarios as well. Levav said: The bias could “happen anywhere where there are sequential decision-making and some kind of status quo or default that allows people to simplify those decisions”.

For example, an inspection officer might do a sloppy job at the end of the day. A doctor in a general hospital may not diagnose a patient’s condition properly before the lunch break. Job interviewers may more likely select early candidates. 

javier matheu AHDeiqdiC7Q unsplash

A Caveat 

A subsequent paper suggests that the ordering of cases was not random. A prisoner without lawyers representing him/her was given slots just before the breaks. Also, prisoners without representation are usually not given parole. The original authors might have confused correlation with causation.  

Further Reading:

- Advertisement -

Leave a Reply


New Star Wars in the Works at Disney+ with Lesley Headland

Star Wars is all set to get a new series from Lesley Headland on Disney Plus and will be a more female-driven action-thriller.

HBO To Make ‘Watchmen’ And Other Titles Free To Stream This Weekend

HBO is highlighting media that explores Black experiences and comes from Black creators. HBO is making Watchmen along with other shows free to stream this June.

Remembering Saroj Khan: The Masterji Of Bollywood

The sudden demise of Saroj Khan has left everyone heartbroken. Let's take a moment to appreciate and recall some of her beautiful choreographies

Hollywood Actors Sign Open Letter About Racism in the Theatre Industry

Hundreds of Hollywood stars have come together to sign an open letter calling out leaders in the American theatre industry for creating bias.

Netflix’s All Because Of You Review: This Malaysian Love Story is Messy

All Because of You is a sloppy and kinda insulting piece of rom-com that fails to be any sort of entertaining.

Loading Next Article